Homes for Sale in Bay Harbor Islands

The median asking price for homes in Bay Harbor Islands is currently $369K, with an average of $709 per square foot. Prices range from $2K to $34.5M depending on property type, size, and location.

There are currently 279 active listings in Bay Harbor Islands. New inventory is added daily — sign up for ELLA alerts to be notified the moment a matching home hits the market.

Bay Harbor Islands offers a variety of property types, with condos, other and single-family being the most common. Condos: 157 listings, Single-Family: 8 listings, Other: 25 listings, Townhouses: 6 listings, Multi-Family: 4 listings. Use Casa Simple's search filters to narrow by property type and find the right fit.

Bay Harbor Islands currently has 63 listings with a recent price reduction, indicating some seller flexibility. With 279 active listings and a median price of $369K, buyers have solid options. ELLA AI can analyze any listing's IQ score, price history, and market trends to help you time your offer strategically.

Casa Simple buyers in Bay Harbor Islands typically receive a rebate of $2K–$5K at closing, based on the median home price of $369K. This is cash back to you from the buyer's agent commission — you pay nothing extra. The exact amount depends on your purchase price and plan.

Traditional home sellers in Bay Harbor Islands pay 5–6% of the sale price in agent commissions. Casa Simple offers a streamlined listing process with transparent pricing, saving most sellers thousands compared to traditional brokerages. Contact us for a free home valuation and cost estimate.